Good or bad comments i think everyone will learn from what they're saying :)
Choir critic... · 3 days ago
Himig Sanghaya is the BEST among the three performers at that night...
Northwind Singers didnt deserve the title.. The girl soloist is screaming, the harmony and the blending sounds not good compare to Himig Sanghaya...
Choir critic... · 3 days ago
Based on the performance.. The Himig Sanghaya's rendition of 214 gives the audience a magical feeling with matching harmony, blending and the chemistry of the two soloist singing it (including the background)...
Compared to Northwind Singers, its just like a typical and generic performance, and i can say that the performances of Blazing sensations and the Northwind Singers are quite the same, same foundation of singing performance...
I'm not Pro-Himig Sanghaya. Hence, it is my own opinion from what I've seen in this Great Glee Sing-off...
Nevertheless, Northwind Singers badly needed that workshop of Trumpets though...
precy minnie♥ · 3 hours ago
that was a bit harsh. :|
Oliver Oliveros · 3 days ago
I believe Himig Sanghaya was once a NAMCYA winner?
Choir Critic · 2 days ago
Yup2, Himig Sanghaya once a NAMCYA winner and hailed Silver-A awardee for the 1st CCP Chorale Competition last year...
They really gave justices for the songs that they've sang in this competition...
ricoboiisagleek · 3 days ago
i agree. I've seen on an article that harmony is like 40% on the criteria?? and i've watched on youtube the 214 of Himig Sanghaya and i thought the Northwind Singers are better off. But, absolutely not, though. I've seen "my life would suck without you" and i believe... sorry to say this.. it SUCKed. what added to the failure of the performances was the failure of the technicals..
well,that is my opinion.. i haven't watched blazing sensations yet, though.
carry on,, carry on.. ~
~ricoboiisagleek. :D
LJZG · 3 days ago
Hello ricoboiisagleek. My name is LJ, and I am a part of Blazing Sensations.
I would also like to agree that technicals sucked. If you would watch our performance of "Taking Chances", there were parts when you couldn't even hear our soloists. We're not sure about it, but from our standpoint, it was also failure of technicals that caused problems for us.
Choir Critic · 2 days ago
Yeah, I agree on you ricoboii... If your are on that place watching them live performing at MOA centerstage, the rendition of himig sanghaya's 214 makes me goosebumps... Adding to it, the microphones of the soloists in himig sanghaya works bad... So the "birits" and the mixing of voices didn't really hear compare to northwind singers, they are all screaming..
Nevertheless, congratulations NORTHWIND SINGERS...
Oliver Oliveros · 2 days ago
Lapels conked out in the middle of the performances =(
Kim · 2 days ago
so what's the point doing this? who deserves the title? syempre mga judge ang huhusga dun. kahit saang competition or contest judge lang ang may karapatan.. di ko napanuod to nabasa ko lang dito.. kaya yung mga talunan wag ng umapila sa barangay na lang kayo magpaliwanag.. ^_^
edward · 2 days ago
for me, northwind did their best:. the performance is great!
juan makabayan · 1 day ago
iT SEEMS some contestant may have INHERITED the ELECTORAL VIRUS - meaning "hindi sila NATALO... NADAYA lang... Hay naku... people GROW UP! Make your protest LEGAL... hindi yun banat ng banat... you can TALK TO THE MARINES...
Larry Parane · 1 day ago
hi guys!
somehow narefer ako sa page na 'to. Some of the posts here about himig are true, like ung sa CCP and NAMCYA. But don't think na prang bakit pa kami sumali sa glee eh ung mga sinasalihan nmin daw bigtime. Well, ung sumali sa glee na members ng himig, un ung, obviously, new generation ng group nmin. Ako lang yta ung nasama dun na 10yrs nang nsa himig. Thank you sa mga comments nyo, nkkatuwa na meron kaming naimpress sa performances nmin. But i'm really happy for the Northwind Singers na nanalo sila. The whole point of doing these stuff, lalo na sa choral groups, is simply to make and enjoy music as we all offer it to the greatest composer of all. Sana we could just accept the decision and enjoy making more music.. Actually, im looking forward na maka-jam nmin ung Northwind and Blazing Sensations, sana makasali uli kami next time. (hoho sana pasok parin ako sa age limit!)
Congrats to all! Glee still rocks!:)
Mr. Male Soloist, Himig Sanghaya. http://www.himigsanghaya.com
P.S.
We did our numbers again kanina sa farewell party ng ibang members nmin, i'm uploading the videos on youtube, hope you guys check it out soon!:) post ko dito links..
Kristian Misa · 1 day ago
oi larry ndi pa tayo nanalo sa nationals ng NAMCYA. Regionals lang, second pa, at saka ndi tayo ganun kagaling (baka kc iniisip ng iba e nagfifeeling tayo). There are a LOT of things that we should improve. Anyway, kanya kanya lang na opinion yan. Basta ako MASAYANG MASAYA ako sa laki ng inimprove ng group natin. I'm very much fulfilled and satisfied with our achievements considering na marami din sa atin ang highschool pa lang pero laban pa din sa nationals. hahaha kaya kayo wag na magtalo kc pointless tapos na e. Ang pwede lang nating makuhang aral sa event na ito ay "wag na mag sound check kc sa performance ndi din naman gagana ang microphones hahahahhaha"!!!
Larry Parane · 18 hours ago
wala nmn akong sinabi na nanalo tau ng nationals ah, hoho
anyway, masaya din ako sa experience nung glee, sana lalo pa tau lahat magimprove =)
Kristian Misa · 7 hours ago
kc may nakita ako nagpost nanalo daw tayo nationals ng namcya e. Anyway, TAMA ka dyan Larry!!! masayang masaya ako sa performance ng mga groups and for that matter, I can say that we all won and learned a lot from this competition. Kaya tama na yang mga pagtatalo. Let's just enjoy music!!!
T CPY · 1 day ago
Well guyz,, IT WAS A GLEE COMPETITION. IT WAS NOT A "CHORALISH, CLASSICAL TYPE, ROBOTIC CHOREOGRAPHY AND MECHANICAL PERFORMANCE THAT THE JUDGES LOOKED DURING THEIR PERFORMANCE. ALONG WITH THE CRITERIA -IT WAS THE HEART, SPONTANEITY, AND ENERGY THAT EVERY PERFORMER SHOULD CONSIDER.
I WAS THERE DURING THE COMPETITION. IN THE MIDDLE 5TH ROW TO BE EXACT.
Godbless and may this be a learning experience to everyone..
CRYOUTLOUD · 1 day ago
NORTHWIND SINGERS - Good blending (with technical error)
- Their voices were not CLASSICAL (THE real glee singing VOICE)
- Excellent costume(fashionistas)
- Excellent choreography(energy, grace and beauty)
- Excellent production appeal (appropriate TV make-up, coordinated costume colors)
HIMIG SANGHAYA - Excellent CLASSICAL blending - GOOD Band- poor costume - poor make-up
- mechanical choreography
KAYO NA ANG MAGSABI KUNG BAKIT NANALO ANG NORTHWIND
boljack # · 3 hours ago
how dare u say it was a mechanical one? ung sa northwind nga dali na ng steps di pa sabaysabay.. mga wla pa sa tono.. u better watch JUMP.
niwey, pwde n ung costume na isa nung sa northwind.. ung ballad yta un.. pero wg sana nating kalimutan na HARMONY ang may pinakataas na percentage sa criteria. i believe in the energy that northwind showed .. PERO HARMONY-wise? i'm sorry, hindi rin. i mean.. HINDI TALAGA.
:D
rose · 1 day ago
YEAH! doon sa mga di satisfied sa result............Do you want to challenge the CREDIBILITY OF THE JUDGES (the COMPANY, SONY and ETC executives)?
Haaay,...Pinoy nga talaga tayo....
sana napanood nyo ng live un performances ng group at saka kayo humusga....etchos...etchos...ek..ek..ek..
liza · 1 day ago
Nanood din po ako...sa isang manonood ang masasabi ko ay magaling pareho ung northwind and himigsanhaya...kulang lng tlga sa energy ung himig..alam mo na kaagad ang mga choreo nilang handmovements to the right and to the left,1,2,3,4, and alternates..
ung sa northwind, may mga sabit blending dahil sa lapel pero mraramdaman mo puso nila at energy..
ung GLEE talaga...
liza · 1 day ago
good day.Im HAPPY AND SAD AT THE SAME TIME, COZ OUR YOUTH ARE SOMEHOW CONFUSED OF WHAT ARE THE DISTINCT CHARACTERISTICS OF A GLEE CLUB AND A CHORALE.LET ME PUT IT THIS WAY: GLEE CLUB VS CHORALE
-uses natural voice(scream when needed) -uses cultured/falsetto voice(round voice-a must)---a show choir (choreo-dancing while singing) -seldom uses choreo(hands movements-a must---a jamming type of singing group -classical/european standard -perfection required--in CONTEXT with the race/nation of the singers -CONSERVATORY MUSIC is the CONTEXT
-HEART/FEELINGS/JOY ARE ESSENTIAL -TECHNIQUE is VERY ESSENTIAL
leoleogleek · 1 day ago
CONGRATULATIONS NORTHWIND... BAKA LALO SILANG NAGAGALIT KZ ALAM NILA THAT YOUR FREE WORKSHOP WITH TRUMPETS WILL MAKE YOU A LOT BETTER !!!
YOU ARE THE REAL GLEE CLUB...CONTINUE SINGING USING NATURAL VOICE!!!!!!!!!! AND DONT GET INTIMIDATED. INSTEAD FOCUS YOUR EYES ON WHAT IS BENEFICIAL FOR YOUR GROUP...
mabuhay ang northwind!!!!
solar. · 1 day ago
come on guys, let's get over it! The competition's finished already, there's no need to brag on. The judges had different opinions on the matter, like on Glee, you'll never know what's their basis for judging. If they enjoyed the winner better than the others, let's just respect that. And for the winners/pro-winners, i think you've done a great job, so to be "better winners", i think you should just enjoy your victory rather than brag how great you were. Instead of telling the blogosphere how amazing you were, how about focus on your weaknesses and be much greater performers? And by the way, Glee is still about singing, more than the choreography.
moY · 1 day ago
Facts to be considered:
- the glee show is about show choir.
- show is very important but without the choir part, show choir is nothing.
- singing is very different from screaming.
- performers that are grounded on humility are the real winners.
- competitions are gauges of each contestant's improvement, not showing which team is better.
jov san juan · 3 hours ago
i believe on the second aspect. "without the choir part, show choir is nothing. "
congrats to himig sanghya's Cristian and Larry "performers that are grounded on humility are the real winners. "
ricodey · 1 day ago
i agree with you solar.congratulations to both himig and northwind. move on..i know both groups have mix emotions to the comments..you might be both hurt to the negative feedbacks. take it as a constructive criticisms for you to improve both.
ricoboiisagleek · 3 hours ago
TAMA! :D
~ricoboiisagleek. :D
sheenagleek · 1 day ago
Thanks for your comments solar and ricodey. 22o ciguro nga, nasasaktan din mga northwind at himig sa mga sinusulat tungkol sa knila. They are victims of people's judgement sa issue na 2..respeto n lng po sa desisyon ng judges. salamat po
Kristian Misa · 1 day ago
ndi pa kami nanalo sa nationals ng NAMCYA. Regionals lang, second pa, at saka ndi tayo ganun kagaling (baka kc iniisip ng iba e nagfifeeling tayo). There are a LOT of things that we should improve. Anyway, kanya kanya lang na opinion yan. Basta ako MASAYANG MASAYA ako sa laki ng inimprove ng group natin. I'm very much fulfilled and satisfied with our achievements considering na marami din sa amin ang highschool pa lang pero laban pa din sa nationals. hahaha kaya kayo wag na kayo magtalo kc pointless tapos na e. Ang pwede lang nating makuhang aral sa event na ito ay "wag na mag sound check kc sa performance ndi din naman gagana ang microphones hahahahhaha"!!! One word of advice: EDUCATE!
HIMIG SANGHAYA MEMBER
Oliver Oliveros · 1 day ago
Whoa, peace guys!
isa · 22 hours ago
Should've, could've, would've... Everybody is entitled to their own opinion. In every competition, there's always a winner probably deemed to serve the purpose of creating awareness for the campaign which in this case, is to get people appreciate show choir music.
I was there and I've appreciated the performance of the finalists. It is a fact that the technicals were downright nasty. I admire the effort put into each song, they were sung with gusto and emotion.
Congratulations everyone for doing your part, you made your teams and supporters proud by making it to the finals. I hope you all stay grounded and remember that there's always room for improvement. Cheers.
Faith · 10 hours ago
It's so easy to say "oh you sucked" or "you don't deserve to win" or "I'm better than you" when you're safely hiding behind a computer. But can you say those exact things to those kids face to face? Please remember that these KIDS are still learning, Himig Sanghaya, Northwind, and Blazing Sensations. I'm so proud of all of them for getting as far as the finals and in truth all of them are winners. Congratulations to all three groups for giving it their bests! Whoever won was not only the judges' choices but God's will. He knows that their win served a greater purpose and meaning to not only the NS but also to HS and BS. Everyone, let's just be happy for them and mature about this!
BeholdtheGleek · 7 hours ago
Para kina:
T CPY na feeling judge,
CRYOUTLOUD na alam lahat,
ROSE na meron pang pachallenge2 ng credibility,
LEOLEOGLEEK na bilib na bilib sa trumpets haha,
LIZA na gumawa pa ng nakakatuwang comparison at nagmamagaling,
cge, kau na. hands down kau na ang magagaling.
and i hope a few years from now, once you've grown to be mature, you'll look backto the posts you created here.
Para kay Choir Critic:
as a fellow blogger, i think okay lang na sabihin nyo opinion nyo sa nangyari pero let's be more cautious sana sa mga sinasabi natin lalo na at maraming nkkbasa ng mga opinion mo.
To Larry Parane and Kristian Misa na mga myembro pala ng HS:
I appreciate your humility. i think tlgang matagal na kayo sa industry na yan because i can see your maturity on the situation. Ganyan ang attitude ng totoong winner. Keep it up guys!
---
I was there during the competition, i'm not affiliated to any contestant. In fact, i was just invited by one of staff. The technicals weren't good. Sayang talaga. The Company had pre-recorded backups except sa solos and adlibs. It was a good event to celebrate music and the results were very similar to the season finale of glee. I've been around this industry for more than 15years and ganun parin tayong mga pinoy when it comes to competition results. nakakatawa.
beholdtheGleek · 7 hours ago
cautious daw samantalang puro pangookray ang nilagay ko pala sa start bwahaha pasensya na at nkkaasar lang talaga ang immaturity nila..
emanon · 28 minutes ago
GOd Bless us all... keep in mind that God has a purpose for everything.....
